Melvin Konner M.D. Ph.D.

The Official Website of Melvin Konner, M.D, Ph.D.

Welcome to my website. Its purpose is to encourage a scientific approach to human nature and experience and to explore the interaction between biology and behavior, medicine and society, nature and culture. Throughout a long life I've been fascinated by why we do what we do, think what we think, feel what we feel. I've sought answers in anthropology, biology, medicine, evolution, brain science, child development, history, and culture...
You are here: Home Is Genocide Now Maladaptive?

Is Genocide Now Maladaptive?

September 2nd, 2012

barbed-wire-photo_1371_20060329

David Blumenthal, a good and wise friend who is a Jewish studies professor and a rabbi wrote me recently asking about the former adaptiveness and present maladaptiveness of xenophobia. The operative passage in his letter was, “In the global world, however, survival requires the cooperation of varying and different groups. Humanity, in its groups, cannot survive without the quintessential other. Xenophobia has ceased to be adaptive. So has antisemitism, racism, orientalism, and misogyny.”

I have little trouble agreeing that at some times in the past these behaviors were adaptive for the perpetrators. Generally, xenophobia must have been adaptive in many times and places, as the people over the hill were surely dangerous, not least because your own people posed a threat to them.

The idea that hunter-gatherers (representing the vast majority of human generations) were genocidal and competed as groups remains controversial, but it has gotten a lot of attention lately, especially in the work of Samuel Bowles and Herbert Gintis, whose 2011 book, A Cooperative Species: Human Reciprocity and its Evolution is a major contribution. In it they argue that the exceptional cooperation and altruism seen in our species (compared to monkeys and apes) is the result of group selection during human evolution. Xenophobia made cooperation within groups adaptive for the group, and more cohesive and self-sacrificing groups destroyed enemies bent on selfishness.

Certainly this cannot be ruled out as a deep pattern in human evolution, but some anthropologists think that serious xenophobia and genocide only arose after agriculture or horticulture made it necessary to stand and defend property, and population densities had reached a point where there was no place to go.

But leaving that aside, the real question you raise is whether xenophobia, antisemitism, racism, orientalism, and misogyny are now maladaptive. I’ll set aside the last and try to address it in another posting. But the first question is, have modern genocides been maladaptive for the perpetrators, regardless of how maladaptive we think they have been for the species—not to mention how immoral they are?

These things are difficult to measure. Germans as a group probably did not gain a net benefit from Nazism, because they paid such a high price in the war. Nevertheless, we see a resurgent and successful Germany in which many perpetrators’ descendants are doing well. The same is true of Poles, Ukrainians, and other European peoples, many of whom avidly aided the Nazis. Meanwhile, the Jews in those countries are gone, having been murdered together with their children and grandchildren, most leaving no descendants, and many non-Jews (reparations aside) have long since occupied and benefited from their homes, stores, property, wealth, etc.

General Ratko Mladic and a few others have paid for the much smaller-scale Serbian genocide in Srebenica, but we would have to know more to feel assured that Serbian Christians in that region have not had a net benefit from the elimination of quite a few thousands of Muslim young men and boys. Grim as it is to start counting, an evolutionary theorist would want to know about the reproductive success of the respective populations since the mid-’90s.

In the case of Rwanda, I would be surprised if it could not be shown that there was a net benefit for the Hutu perpetrators at the expense of their 800,000 or so Tutsi victims. Some retaliation occurred but on nothing like the same scale, and the reconciliation process—I’m not saying it’s a bad idea—pretty much guarantees that the perpetrators will never pay remotely the kind of price they imposed on the victims. I don’t know who now benefits from the property of those victims, or for that matter from their permanent removal from competition for resources, but I would not be surprised if some of the perpetrators consider the genocide to have been fairly successful in achieving its primary goals, and I am not sure they would be wrong.

So, alas, I cannot conclude that genocide is any less adaptive for the perpetrators now than it was in most of human history. If we consider the human species as a whole, I certainly think it is maladaptive, but that is not the way we usually calculate reproductive advantage, because it is advantage gained by individuals and, perhaps, groups that has up to now always determined what would evolve. For the forseeable future too, some groups will still seek success at the expense of other groups.

Can we construct a world system in which we impose such costs on perpetrators (as groups, not just their leaders) that they truly hesitate when the next opportunity to benefit from genocide comes up? I don’t think we have done this yet. Many believe that the US and the USSR were each prevented from exterminating the other by the nuclear balance of terror, but this might be hard to do in a multicentric world. Ultimately there would have to be a reliable governing body—something much more effective than the UN—that would ensure a costly and consistent multinational response to perpetrators.

None of these calculations, of course, changes the ethical imperative to oppose and prevent genocide, or for that matter xenophobia, racism, or war. But the above arguments offer some idea of why I am wary of trying to shore up ethical positions by referring to adaptation in the evolutionary sense of the word.

I’ll have something to say about misogyny soon.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

319 Responses to “Is Genocide Now Maladaptive?”

  1. OrvigoMax says:

    OrvigoMax…

    Is Genocide Now Maladaptive? » Melvin Konner’s Blog…

  2. creative.eocc.co…

    Is Genocide Now Maladaptive? » Melvin Konner’s Blog…

  3. High quality dental-implants worldwide…

    Is Genocide Now Maladaptive? » Melvin Konner’s Blog…

  4. Professional oral instruments for dentists…

    Is Genocide Now Maladaptive? » Melvin Konner’s Blog…

  5. I intended to send you the little bit of observation to help thank you so much once again for your personal magnificent principles you have shown here. It has been so surprisingly open-handed of people like you to give extensively all most of us would have made available as an e-book to help with making some profit on their own, notably considering the fact that you might well have done it if you ever decided. Those suggestions also worked to be a fantastic way to realize that the rest have the same dream like mine to figure out very much more regarding this issue. I am certain there are thousands of more pleasant instances ahead for people who view your blog.

  6. Thankfulness to my father who shared with me regarding this website, this website is
    really remarkable.

    Take a look at my web page: make a blog for free

  7. ottimo articolo, complimenti

  8. In exactly the same sense, companies would be wise to give their workers something to unite
    under. An attention grabbing attractive website is essential within the technologically advanced and highly competitive market
    of current age, for the success of business. A well-developed business plan is much like
    your blueprint for victory.

    Take a look at my web blog - http://www.rylabogados.com.ar

  9. Thanks in support of sharing such a good thought, paragraph
    is nice, thats why i have read it completely

  10. Very great post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I’ve truly loved surfing around your
    weblog posts. In any case I will be subscribing in your
    feed and I am hoping you write once more soon!

  11. Yes! Finally something about skin problems.

    Feel free to surf to my web blog - stunning nail

  12. Exercise says:

    Exercise…

    Is Genocide Now Maladaptive? » Melvin Konner’s Blog…

  13. Azucena says:

    Thanks to my father whho stated to me about this web site, this blog is really remarkable.

  14. Thanks on your marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading
    it, you can be a great author.I will remember to bookmark your blog and may come back at some point.
    I want to encourage you to continue your great job, have a nice
    morning!

  15. Sugiere, además de esto, que la industria cinematográfica europea podría
    aumentar sus ingresos explotando diferentes tipos de plataformas on-line, con ánimo de lucro, que ofrecieran más películas y dejaran llegar a un público más extenso.

    Su apoyo a la distribución y a la elaboración de películas puede ofrendar a los realizadores nuevas
    perspectivas, que enriquecerán la diversidad cultural de
    Europa y dejarán que un número mayor de espectadores accedan a películas de gran calidad”, ha declarado Androulla Vassiliou, Comisaria
    Europea de Educación, Cultura, Multilingüismo y Juventud.

  16. My relatives all the time say that I am killing my time here
    at net, however I know I am getting experience every day by reading such good
    posts.

  17. Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Many thanks for supplying this
    information.

  18. Misha says:

    I am so appreciative to Maneet Bhatia as he has so cllraey described how essential it is to accept and encourage adaptive emotional expression with boys and men in sports. I strongly recommend that coaches, counselors, and parents share this interview with young people in order for them to learn that emotional expression in sports is natural and essential to developing and maintaining an ultimate level of physical and emotional health. Kristin A.R. OsbornCo-Director, Harvard Medical School Psychotherapy Research Programat Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center

  19. Farshid says:

    I really co’undlt ask for more from this article.

Leave a Reply


Blog Navigation

Selected Books

  • JoomlaWorks Simple Image Rotator
  • JoomlaWorks Simple Image Rotator
  • JoomlaWorks Simple Image Rotator
  • JoomlaWorks Simple Image Rotator
  • JoomlaWorks Simple Image Rotator

Login Form